There are several headlines today that speak to one of the most pressing issues that we have with the pace of energy transition – the competition for renewable power and the likely inability of the industry to keep up with the competing needs, let alone do so without significant power cost inflation.
The WSJ article linked talking about rising ESG spending and the risks associated with it is in no way inconsistent with our view that lack of US Government guidelines is constraining ESG spending. The article focuses on the power and auto industries, which, while they face regulatory and incentive uncertainty, have a much clearer path than many others. The power industry is dealing with a customer which is increasingly asking for more renewable power, an investor base that is pushing for less reliance on fossil fuels, and a Government that is pushing for a 50% emissions reduction from the sector. The auto suppliers have clear directives from some US states and some countries about the phasing out of fossil fuel-based vehicle sales, and in some geographies, they have incentive systems that they can tap into. For both industries, there is a significant risk, in that the billions of dollars that they are investing in new plants and new equipment do not come with any guarantees that those investments will pay off well or quickly, but at least the direction of travel is unlikely to change. In other words, there will be demand for their products and investors will likely be happy with the progress – while they might not get the EBITDA they would like, they may get a better multiple of that EBITDA.
Finally, Larry Fink has recognized the flaw in his aggressive ESG rhetoric. Maybe he knew this all along, but it is good to see him step into the debate in favor of not crippling the fossil fuel industry by denying it access to capital and investors too quickly. However, that boat may have sailed, with investors like Engine No. 1 feeling empowered by their win over ExxonMobil and raising more money as a consequence. We have covered this subject at length in our ESG and climate weekly this week: Big Oil’s Big Problem – Hard To Find A Favorable Scenario – maybe Larry read it!
There are too many important topics to choose from today and we will cover many of these in our ESG and Climate report tomorrow. Here we focus on the IEA report published this week, which shows a path to net-zero on a global scale and looks at both the fossil fuel consuming sectors and the rate at which each must change (they are different by sector) and what fuel alternatives will be needed to replace them. Our review of the work would suggest the following: