Following on from the LyondellBasell commentary in today's daily report, we would make one further, but very important point. With its refinery (granted the company is exploring opportunities to exit) and its huge commodity polyethylene, polypropylene, and propylene oxide business, any attempt to pursue a “specialty” strategy that encompasses the whole portfolio will be seen (crudely) as trying to put some lipstick on a pig! This rarely works in the chemical sector and the real transformation stories involve wholesale portfolio shifts, many of which have taken notable periods of time to develop. We still believe that the right path for LyondellBasell is to spin off the good piece – recycling, licensing, and compounding, or even better, find someone they can sell the business to through a Reverse Morris Trust. This strategy would likely allow the company to pay down (or shift) a significant amount of debt. The commodity business can then focus on the best strategy for a commodity polymer business in the face of energy transition, which might involve taking the business private or merging with another.
The ACC forecasts below leave us a little confused as the implication for specialty chemicals is that production declines in the US by an average of 2.0% per annum from 2019 to 2023. Given the demand that we are seeing for US manufacturing, as covered in our most recent Sunday Report, we would expect demand for all inputs to rise and it is unlikely that the gap would be filled by a swing in net imports. The lower demand from the Auto industry in 2020 and 2021 and broader manufacturing shutdowns in 2020 explains the 2020 and 2021 numbers to a degree, but it is not clear why there would not be a rebound as auto rates increase. We would also expect to see a stronger rebound in polymer production in 2022, assuming weather events are less impactful than in 2021, given substantial new capacity for polyethylene from ExxonMobil/SABIC, BayStar, and Shell.
The advanced nature of the ExxonMobil/SABIC project, which we have discussed previously, is another cause for concern around US polyethylene market strength for a couple of reasons. First, it is only the first wave, with Baystar and Shell hot on the heels in 1H 2020. Second, it will add another ethylene seller in the US – SABIC – and this may be enough to cause some ripples. If you look at this in the context of the Asia production growth data provided by the ACC (below) there should be a significant cause for concern around the global balance for many products. Some of the specific Asia country growth, year on year and year to date, is driven by COVID-related shutdowns in 2020 – Taiwan and Malaysia for example – but the bulk of the China growth, which is more significant in absolute volume terms is from new capacity. China’s ability to sell surpluses internationally is hindered by the current logistic problems, but these will not last, and we should also factor in where the material will go that had been imported into China. The global polyethylene market could look very different in 2022, although all eyes will be focused on Hurricane Ida for the next week. See more in today's daily report.