It is interesting to note the rapid rise in US propylene (and benzene) values as they follow propane and crude prices (propane is following crude because of its heating value and export opportunities). Ethylene is not moving as US natural gas is in surplus and is not following international natural gas prices. The US is surplus ethylene and derivatives, but we would expect to see ethylene and ethylene derivative prices jump up in the US if Europe is physically unable to make ethylene and derivatives or if the costs in Europe become so high that supplying incremental volumes from the US becomes even more compelling. For more see today's report titled "Into The Mystic – Ex-US Energy Price Surge Favors US Producers; Low Visibility Keeps Capex In Check".
The run-up in ethylene spot prices in the US is interesting because it takes away most of the export arbitrage to Asia, as summarized in the charts below. Our margins models suggest that Asis is losing money making ethylene from imported naphtha today – especially in China and the arbitrage looks more interesting for US exporters of ethylene if you look at China costs as opposed to China prices for ethylene. The US remains a preferred supplier of ethylene to parts of Asia that would otherwise import from more local producers as our local cost analysis does not include a freight component. For example, an ethylene buyer in Southeast Asia could still get material from the US cheaper – even with higher US prices – than from China or other local exporters. For more on ethylene and propylene markets see our Daily
We have seen relative stability in US spot ethylene and propylene prices for several weeks now, despite some volatility in feedstock markets. Ethylene likely has significant export support in that there are complexes in Asia that are net short of ethylene and where derivative production can be increased if ethylene is available at the right price. There are also displacement opportunities if US ethylene can be delivered to importers in Asia at lower prices than local production costs. This is broadly the case today and there may even be select opportunities in Europe. In Asia it is likely easier, as the buyer would be replacing an alternate supplier. In Europe, most potential buyers would be looking at cutting back their own local production and that is a more marginal decision given the impact on unit economics of lower operating rates. US propylene demand remains high, but prices are now settling closer to PDH costs, although not close enough to encourage anyone to slow production. See more in today's daily report!
Following on from the Enterprise comments covered in our daily report, the company is more likely to acquire something in chemicals than build it in our view, especially if a move into ethylene or polymers is on the table. Today, building capacity will come with all sorts of emission-related restrictions most likely, and many of the new build announcements we have seen since COP26 have come with a carbon plan (Dow, Air Product, and Borouge). While it is not obvious today that any Gulf Coast ethylene capacity is up for sale, we would imagine that most companies are reviewing strategy and evaluating whether they have assets of entire businesses that may have a better owner. This would be especially true if a basic chemical business is holding back the valuation of a more interesting core. In the recent past, we have talked about the relative value arbitrage open to LyondellBasell from separating its compounding, licensing, and recycling business from the core. Maybe the core would fit well with Enterprise? As the chart below shows, there is money in buying ethylene for export, but there is more money in the US in making ethylene, as discussed in our daily report.
The Navigator Gas announcement should not be a surprise as the ethylene export arbitrage reopened in the US in September (Exhibit below) and since the terminal opened there has been a demand for ethylene exports each time the numbers have made sense. There are ethylene consumers in Asia that are net short and will buy incremental volumes from the US when the price is right relative to local suppliers and there is incremental demand in countries and regions that appear to be in surplus, including Europe, where a buyer can leverage an import to try to push local prices lower. In China, some of the facilities that require either propane or ethane imports might be better off buying ethylene versus making it today, and this is certainly the case for naphtha importers, as we highlighted in our Weekly Catalyst report on Monday. Today a US exporter can buy spot ethylene in the US and deliver it to China for less than the cost of manufacture in China, before the cost of getting the local ethylene to any consumer that is not on site.
We are seeing some stability in ethylene and propylene pricing in the US to start the week, and with the steady rise in crude prices and the Monday jump in natural gas prices, this is not surprising. As we noted in yesterday’s Weekly Catalyst, there is enough incentive to export ethylene from the US to Asia – most likely Southeast Asia rather than North Asia, and this could offer support for those with surplus ethylene in the US today.
The ACC May production data shows the very strong year on year production growth globally, with the US gains more muted than the rest of the world as the COVID production impact in May of 2020 was less severe in the US than in many other parts of the world, and the China growth has been further assisted by significant capacity additions since this time last year. It is interesting to note that on a year to date basis the US is still down year-on-year, which is the lingering impact of the winter storm on production and it reflects that there is not much space capacity in the US, given both the strong demand and the export economic advantage of lower feedstock costs. Despite the collapse in prices in Asia – very well reflected in Exhibit 1 in today's daily report – the US has enough margin to continue its derivative and ethylene exports.