We are seeing some stability in ethylene and propylene pricing in the US to start the week, and with the steady rise in crude prices and the Monday jump in natural gas prices, this is not surprising. As we noted in yesterday’s Weekly Catalyst, there is enough incentive to export ethylene from the US to Asia – most likely Southeast Asia rather than North Asia, and this could offer support for those with surplus ethylene in the US today.
We will expand on the Olin results and some of the benefits and potential pitfalls of the revised strategy in our Sunday piece as we can draw some comparisons (some good and some bad) from other corporate examples over time. For now, it is working and few would have predicted a $50+ stock for Olin a year ago. Some market fundamentals are working in Olin’s favor, but much of the success is coming from a more radical approach to customer engagement and avoidance of customers generating minimal returns, regardless of what that means for production. So far this is a great first act from the new leadership of Scott Sutton – we will talk about what a second act may need to look like on Sunday.
The Venture Global LNG contracts with Sinopec are likely the big energy news of the day, as is the expectation that the West Louisiana terminal is close to completion and could begin shipping as soon as late 2021, according to a report in the Financial Times today. This would be earlier than prior guidance and will add demand pressure to a US natural gas balance that is already tight (distracted in the immediate term in our view by a wave of mild weather). With Venture Global now likely to go ahead with its second LNG facility, as well as other capacities under construction, we will likely see greater inflation in US natural gas prices without increased E&P spending.
The propylene chart below shows a significant disconnect between spot and contract prices – more than at any point in recent history, and if the US contract price does not fall it will likely be an indicator that either discounts have increased or that more volume is moving against a spot price marker. The pressure is also on to lower ethylene contract prices, but the propylene spread is far more extreme.
The US propylene to propane spread finished this week within the 5-year range, as opposed to setting the high end of the 5-year range, for the first time since December 2020. It still has a long way to go to reach seasonal 5-year averages and even further to reach seasonal lows, and there is plenty of margin left in PDH production in the US, even if the returns are now much lower than they were only a couple of months ago. Propylene pricing in the US is now low enough to encourage all derivative units to operate at high rates and we expect derivative price declines to follow – perhaps as steeply as propylene in the spot markets but more slowly in the contract markets.
As we hinted in yesterday's report, the wheels are wobbling in the US market, especially for polyolefins and this comes at a time when Asia prices are finding some strength because of production and cost issues – it shows how quickly market dynamics can change in this industry and the closing of the gap between Asia and US propylene prices in the first exhibit below is perhaps the most dramatic example. We see a real opportunity for the wheels to stop wobbling and completely fall of the western wagons in the near term, and as the second exhibit below shows propylene continues lower, and with further to fall to hit PDH economics.
With the rapid rise in energy prices, we are seeing price increase announcements for many intermediate chemicals, especially in regions of the world where margins were already very slim. The energy inflation issue is hard to call, with more and more commentators suggesting that it could be prolonged (which generally means it will be short), but lots of dislocations support duration. We would certainly be pushing prices today on the back of energy costs that could move higher again, and given that many chemical and polymer buyers have price protection in their contracts (for at least a month), producers could face a margin squeeze and an uphill climb to get adequate price coverage. Seasonally, demand for chemicals and polymers is at its weakest for the next couple of months, so the price hikes may be difficult. However, because of supply chain constraints, buyers may feel less confident and concede more easily. We could see a significant swing in sentiment from the chemical companies on 3Q earnings calls over the coming weeks as they talk about how good results were in 3Q but throw up all sorts of cautionary statements concerning 4Q.
Our latest Sunday Thematic report, "Damned if you Dow and Damned if you Down’t. Hard to win", centers around Dow's announced development of a new net-zero carbon emissions site in Alberta, Canada. It discusses company-specific and sector ramifications for Dow's strategic move to produce low-cost low carbon polyethylene in Canada while also expanding capacity.
While we will talk more about the Dow project in Alberta on Sunday, one of the problems that the stock faces in the light of the announcement is largely unrelated, which is the growing expectation that margins in 2022 will be significantly lower than in 2021. This is the view coming out of the recent EPCA meeting and as the ethylene/propylene chart below shows, monomer pricing is already weakening in the US as production ramps back up following the recent storms – we note in Exhibit 1 from today's daily report the squeeze on ethylene margins as prices fall, while costs rise. But it is also worth noting that margins remain quite healthy, while well below their highs. Those companies who built new ethylene capacity in the US over the last 5 years would have had a margin similar to the current level shown in Exhibit 1 in an optimistic capital case.
Even with the inflated container rates, the vast price difference between US and Asia polypropylene prices makes the opportunity too great to ignore. Even at their highest levels, container rates, and inland transport costs likely total no more than 35 cents per pound today, and as shown in the Exhibit below, you have plenty of room to maneuver. This is not the case with polyethylene or other polymers where the price delta between the regions, while high, does not cover the costs and the added risk of delays to sourcing. For more see today's daily.